Urgent: Protest Regarding Factual Errors in Review - Submission ll-rg-MOlPGIPC
Hi Co-pilot and the Topcoder Team,
I am writing to bring attention to a significant factual error in the review of my submission (ID: ll-rg-MOlPGIPC). While the challenge is now marked as "Completed," the review process for my submission appears to have missed critical evidence.
1. Factual Error regarding Validation Video:
Reviewer 2 (sah2ed) assigned a score of 0.00, stating "No submission video." However, the file 'Screenrecorder-Validation_Video (1).mp4' was clearly included in the root of the submission package. Even in the reviewer's own list of files, this video is present. It is highly unfair to fail a submission based on the claim that a required file is missing when it is factually there.
2. AI vs. Human Score Discrepancy:
My submission was thoroughly vetted by the AI Reviewers, receiving scores of 97/100 (GPT-4.1), 89.5/100 (GPT-OSS), and 81/100 (Gemini). These scores verify the technical logic and infrastructure (CDK) are correct. In contrast, the human review resulted in a 12.34 Fail, primarily due to the "scattered" file structure—a 75% deduction that seems disproportionate given the AI-verified technical merit.
I have already reached out via the Contact Manager, but I am posting here to request a manual re-check of the video evidence and a fairer technical evaluation. A "0.00" based on a missing file that exists is a clear oversight that needs correction.
Best regards,
demo_1